Revista Mexicana Ciencias Agrícolas   volume 14   number 2   February 15 - March 31, 2023

DOI: https://doi.org/10.29312/remexca.v14i2.3015

Article

Allelopathic effect of Metopium brownei and Viguiera dentata
on Senna uniflora

Abigail Malerva-Díaz1

Bernardino Candelaria-Martínez1

Norma Laura Rodríguez-Ávila1§

1Postgraduate in Sustainable Agroecosystems-Campus Technological Institute of China-National Technological of Mexico. 11th Street between 22 and 28, Center, China, Campeche, Mexico. CP. 24050. (abigail-tec1@hotmail.com; bernardino.cm@china.tecnm.mx). Tel. 986 8665432.

§Corresponding author: norma.ra@china.tecnm.mx.

Abstract

Allelopathy is a biological phenomenon in which chemicals released by one plant species directly influence the growth and development of another; therefore, allelopathic species can be a natural source of herbicides. Metopium brownei and Viguiera dentata have been shown to have an inhibitory effect on plants and microorganisms. The present work aimed to determine the suppressive effect of different doses of crude extracts of M. brownei and V. dentata on the in vitro germination of a tropical weed (Senna uniflora) and Raphanus sativus, a species highly sensitive to allelochemicals. It was shown that aqueous extracts of M. brownei fruits applied at doses as low as 0.5% suppressed the germination of the weed S. uniflora by 100%. The ethanolic extracts of both species demonstrated an inhibitory effect on the germination of S. uniflora seeds at concentrations of 8% or higher. On the other hand, aqueous extracts of V. dentata flowers were the most effective in inhibiting the germination of R. sativus seeds when applied in doses higher than 15%. According to the results obtained in the present work, it is concluded that V. dentata has a strong allelopathic effect on S. uniflora when used in ethanolic and aqueous extracts, so it can be used as a bioherbicide for the control of the weed in tropical crops.

Keywords: allelopathy, bioherbicides, natural extracts, weeds.

Reception date: December 2022

Acceptance date: February 2023

Introduction

In Mexico, agriculture is an activity of great importance for local, national and international economic development (Macías, 2013). The control of weeds represents one of the main problems to be solved with a view to achieving improvements in agricultural production by reducing costs. In this sense, herbicides that have negative effects on the environment have traditionally been used, causing damages to soil biodiversity and human health (Oliva and Peña, 2004).

A specific example is the use of glyphosate, whose residues such as aminomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA) accumulate in soil and water, causing bioaccumulation in plants, animals and humans, given its high persistence in the environment (Martins-Gomes et al., 2022). Likewise, the herbicide 2,4-D has been proven to cause serious health problems in humans, in addition to the ecotoxicological effect it has on aquatic and plant life (Islam et al., 2018). Similarly, atrazine has a high toxicity and accumulates in surface and groundwater (Hansen et al., 2013).

For its part, paraquat, another widely used herbicide and whose form of action is as a respiration blocker, causes a high rate of intoxication and mortality in mammals and its persistence in the environment is also prolonged (Hernández et al., 2008; Rojas, 2018). An alternative to solve this problem is the development of products based on the use of plant species that have been shown to have suppressive effects on the growth and development of weeds, at a lower cost to the environment (Dousseau et al., 2008; Celis et al., 2009; Oliveira et al., 2015).

This inhibitory effect of one plant species on another, mediated by interaction with secondary metabolites, is known as allelopathy; and secondary metabolites that are released into the environment by allelopathic species are known as allelochemicals. An example of these are extracts from the leaves and seeds of Canavalia ensiformis, whose bioherbicidal effect has been proven on Grandifolia ipomoea and G. benghalensis (Mendes and Rezende, 2014). The allelopathic effect in many cases manifests itself in inhibition of germination, plant growth, bud development and root (Sahu and Devkota, 2013).

In tropical crops, Senna uniflora (known in some parts of Mexico as ‘Cacahuatillo’) is a species that is considered a weed in the Yucatán Peninsula and elsewhere in Mexico (Francisco, 2018), whose seeds have the ability to go dormant during times of drought, germinate and grow vigorously in the rainy season (Figueroa and Galeano, 2007). This species has a high presence in tropical crops such as passion fruit (Muraira et al., 2016), corn, beans, rice, sugarcane and cotton, coffee and tobacco (Alipi and Flores, 2013), probably due to its allelopathic effect on other weed species (Swati et al., 2014), so it easily becomes dominant in the crops in which it is present and may even inhibit the growth of the cultivated species.

According to the above, it is an interesting study model to test the effect of new herbicides, especially those formulated from allelochemicals. On the other hand, Metopium brownei and Viguiera dentata have a wide distribution in the Yucatán Peninsula, whose allelopathic potential on other plants or microorganisms has been reported in different studies.

Therefore, in this study the aqueous and ethanolic extracts prepared from different organs of both allelopathic species were evaluated to know their effects on the germination of Senna uniflora. The above in order to establish the bases that enable the development of a safe and effective bioherbicide product for the control of weeds characteristic of the Yucatán Peninsula.

Materials and methods

Samples of leaves, fruits, bark and roots of M. brownei trees; as well as of leaves, stems, flowers and roots of shrubs of V. dentata were collected. The collections were carried out at the Xamantún experimental ranch, of the Technological Institute of Chiná. The samples were stored in refrigeration until disinfection, using a 5% sodium hypochlorite solution for 10 min. Once this was done, they were rinsed with plenty of sterile water and dehydrated at 55 °C in an industrial oven for three days.

The dehydrated material was crushed and macerated for 72 h with 96% absolute ethanol at room temperature or distilled water (at 4 °C), at a rate of 1:3 v/v (plant material/solvent). Subsequently, the evaluation of the phytotoxicity of the extracts was carried out by soaking Whatman grade 3 filter paper discs with 1 ml of the extracts to be evaluated diluted to obtain concentrations of 0.3, 0.5, 1, 2.5, 8, 15 and 20% (Table 1), similar to the technique reported by Uribe (2008) to evaluate phytotoxic extracts in onions and soybeans.

Table 1. Effect of aqueous and ethanolic extracts of Metopium brownei and Viguiera dentata on the germination of Raphanus sativus seeds.

Mb= Metopium brownei; Vd= Viguiera dentata; C-= negative control (water); C+= positive control (pyrocatechol); a,b,c= different literals in the same column indicate a statistically significant difference (Tukey, p≤ 0.05).

The solvents were previously removed from the extracts with the use of a rotary evaporator. In the bioassays, seeds of Senna uniflora and Raphanus sativus were used as recipient species, the latter species because of its susceptibility to allelochemicals (Othman et al., 2012; Rahman et al., 2022). To do this, the seeds were disinfected with a chlorine solution (10 ml L-1) placing 10 on the discs already soaked with the dilutions of extracts.

The treatments were subjected to experimentation until observing the germination of all the seeds in the negative control bottles (sterile distilled water). Pyrocatechol (35 mg L-1) was used as a positive control. The phytotoxic effect was determined by calculating the percentage of germination obtained in each treatment. Data were analyzed by a one-way Anova and Tukey’s test of means (p= 0.05), using the Infostat V. 2017 software.

Results and discussion

Table 1 shows that aqueous and ethanolic extracts of M. brownei and M. brownei affected the germination of R. sativus seeds. This effect had different intensities of the inhibition of seed germination according to the type of extract, concentration of the extract and tissue of the allelopathic plant in question. It was observed that the aqueous extracts of V. dentata obtained from leaves, the application of a dose greater than 8% resulted in an inhibition of germination of about 70%.

Likewise, extracts obtained from flowers caused 100% inhibition of germination from a dose of 15%. In general, these extracts were more effective than those obtained from the different organs of M. brownei. With respect to ethanolic extracts, those obtained from leaves of M. brownei led to a 100% inhibition of the germination of radish seeds when applied in doses from 8%, the most effective being those isolated from fruits, bark and root, applied in doses of 2.5% or higher.

On the other hand, the extracts prepared with leaves of V. dentata were the most effective among those prepared with the plant material of this species, inhibiting germination by 100% by applying them also at doses of 2.5% or higher. The extracts obtained from its other organs reached the same effectiveness from the dose of 8%. Therefore, in general it can be established that ethanolic extracts of both species are effective in inhibiting the germination of radish seeds when applied in doses as low as 2.5%. However, the aqueous and ethanolic ones applied at low doses promoted germination (Table 1).

There are reports of several plant extracts that have been evaluated, demonstrating effectiveness similar to that observed in this study. Similarly, studies carried out with aqueous extracts show that they can inhibit or promote plant germination and development, depending on the dose applied. For example, extracts from leaves of 25 Bangladeshi leguminous plants inhibited the germination and growth of radish shoots, confirming their allelopathic activity (Rahman et al., 2022), in contrast, another study showed that some doses of extracts from the root and aerial parts of Deverra tridariata stimulated the germination and vegetative growth of Triticum aestivum L. (Guetat et al., 2022).

Similarly, extracts of Tectona grandis L. and Tagetes erecta L. inhibited the germination of seeds of cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.), okra (Hibiscus esculentus L.), radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.), while stimulating the germination of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Similarly, aqueous extracts of Calotropis procera applied in high doses (between 40 and 60%) delayed the germination of seeds of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.), fenugreek (Trigonella foenum graecum L.) and septic weed (Senna occidentalis L. Link), while at lower doses (5%), they stimulated the growth of cucumber, septic weed and fenugreek seedlings, even more than the control treatment (Al-Zahrani and Al-Robai, 2007).

Therefore, it is important to consider that allelopathic plant extracts also have active substances capable of promoting faster and more uniform germination (Carrillo-Martínez et al., 2018). For example, lactones have been proven to stimulate plant growth and development (Aristizábal et al., 2017). On the other hand, the application of secondary metabolites can induce the release of phenolic compounds involved in stress defense physiology (Hernández and González, 2010).

This accumulation of phenols has been detected in high quantities in the vacuole and in the cell walls of various species, leading to phenolic oxidation and growth inhibition in woody plants (Jácome and Rojas 2017). Similar phenolization effects were observed in this study in R. sativus seeds treated with organic extracts obtained from the plant organs of M. brownei, such as that of leaves (1E), bark (1H) and root (1N), applied at 20% (Figure 1). It is possible to attribute the low percentages of germination observed to this phenomenon.

Figure 1. Effect of ethanolic extracts of Metopium brownei on Raphanus sativus seeds. A) control; B) control+; C) leaf extract at 8%; D) leaf extract at 15%; E) leaf extract at 20%; F) bark extract at 8%; G) bark extract at 15%; H) bark extract at 20%; I) fruit extract at 8%; J) fruit extract at 15%; K) fruit extract at 20%; L) root extract at 8%; M) root extract at 15%; and N) root extract at 20%.

In the study region, V. dentata is an herbaceous plant whose biomass is not used and once it has passed its flowering stage, it ends up drying out and being lost in the environments in which it is present. According to the results obtained from bioassays with radish seeds, ethanolic extracts prepared from leaves of this species are postulated as a good bioherbicide alternative, given their high effectiveness and that, in biomass, the leaves exceed the remaining plant organs, which would facilitate the preparation of a product for application in sustainable agriculture.

Based on the above, it was proposed to evaluate the phytotoxicity of extracts on seeds of the weed S. uniflora. Table 2 shows that extracts from the leaves of M. brownei had the best effects in the inhibition of the germination of this weed. Specifically, the aqueous extracts of its fruits inhibited 100% the germination of S. uniflora from the concentration of 0.5 to 20%. In the germination values obtained from the application of aqueous extracts of bark and root, there were no significant differences, although it is worth mentioning that the germination was lower than that obtained in the negative control (water).

Table 2. Effect of aqueous and ethanolic extracts of Metopium brownei and Viguiera on the germination of Senna uniflora seeds.

Mb= Metopium brownei; Vd= Viguiera dentata; C-= negative control (water); C+= positive control (pyrocatechol). a,b,cDifferent literals in the same column indicate a statistically significant difference (Tukey, p≤ 0.05).

The extracts from M. brownei leaves had a greater effect on germination inhibition. Specifically, aqueous extracts of fruits inhibited 100% from the concentration of 0.5%. In the germination values obtained from the application of aqueous extracts of bark and root, there were no significant differences.

With the aqueous extracts of V. dentata obtained from leaves, the lowest percentage of germination was obtained when compared with the extracts obtained from its other organs and in general, they were less effective than the aqueous extracts of M. brownei. With respect to ethanolic extracts, those obtained from leaves of M. brownei led to an inhibition of 100% of the germination of S. uniflora from the concentration of 1%. Similarly, ethanolic extracts of V. dentata were more efficient in controlling the germination of the grass than aqueous extracts obtained from the same species.

In this way, doses above 8% led to 100% inhibition, especially when using extracts prepared with roots, stems and flowers of V. dentata. It is important to note that, although high percentages of germination were observed with some treatments, in all cases these remained below the values observed in the negative control (water). Thus, although in some cases the suppressive effect was mild, all the extracts evaluated had a negative effect on the germination of S. uniflora.

The extracts of various species evaluated in other studies demonstrate a lower effectiveness than that observed with the extracts evaluated in this study. For example, aqueous extracts of Azadirachta indica A. Juss, Murraya koenigii (Linn.) Spreng and Paederia foetida Linn used at doses of 10% on Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek demonstrated a low suppressive efficiency, observing a germination of 73.3%, when applied at a rate of 5% there was a germination of 80% and when applied in doses of 1% there was a germination of 86.7%.

On the other hand, the extracts of Paederia foetida, a germination of 76.7% was obtained with the concentration of 10%, while a high percentage of germination, of 93.3%, was obtained with the concentration of 5% and with the concentration of 1% there was a germination of 96.7% (Kakati and Baruah, 2013). Some authors emphasize that the inhibitory activity of allelopathic extracts depends on the concentrations of extract used; the species of donor and recipient plants also influence.

It is even possible to obtain a positive effect on plant germination and growth, similar to the behavior observed in some of the highest concentrations evaluated in this work. For instance, in a study in which aqueous extracts of Ruta graveolens, Baccharis alnifolia and Caesalpinia spinosa were evaluated in the germination of Chenopodium album, Amaranthus hybridus and Brassica rapa subsp., it was found that those obtained from R. graveolens roots stimulated the germination of B. rapa (Calderón, 2018).

Similarly, aqueous extracts isolated from V. dentata flowers in doses of 2.5% appear to be promoting the germination of S. uniflora. Figure 2 shows the effects produced by ethanolic extracts of M. brownei. In general, necrosis of the seeds is observed, verifying the lethal effect of all treatments from dilution at 8%. A similar effect is observed in seed treated with pyrocatechol (2B).

Figure 2. Seeds of Senna uniflora after being subjected to different doses of M. brownei. A) control-; B) control+; C) leaf extract at 8%; D) leaf extract at 15%; E) leaf extract at 20%; F) flower extract at 8%; G) flower extract at 15%; H) flower extract at 20%; I) bark extract at 8%; J) bark extract at 15%; K) bark extract at 20%; L) root extract at 8%; M) root extract at 15%; and N) root extract at 20%.

Finally, Figure 3 shows the effects produced by the ethanolic extracts of M. brownei on the initial development of Senna uniflora seedlings. In general, points of necrosis on the leaves and stem, chlorosis and root inhibition are observed.

Figure 3. Seeds of Senna uniflora after being subjected to different doses of ethanolic extracts of M. brownei. A) Phenolized seed, product of treatment with leaf extract at 1%; B) seedlings derived from treatment with fruit extract at 1%; C) seedlings derived from treatment with fruit extract at 2.5%; and D) phenolized seedling, derived from treatment with bark extract at 1%.

Conclusions

The aqueous and ethanolic extracts of Metopium brownei and Viguiera dentata have an allelopathic effect responsible for inhibiting the germination of seeds of the tropical weed Senna uniflora and Raphanus sativus. The species M. brownei has a higher inhibitory effect when fruits are used to obtain extracts, while V. dentata was more efficient when leaves were used to obtain extracts. Both species have potential to be used as bioherbicides in tropical crops.

Acknowledgements

To the National Technological Institute of Mexico for the resources granted for the development of the present research project (6380.19-P).

Cited literature

Alipi, A. M. H. y Flores, R. E. G. 2013. Costa norte de Nayarit, indicios de la vegetación que una vez fue. Rev. Fue. Nue. Épo. 4(12):23-36.

Al-Zahrani, H. S. and Al-Robai, S. A. 2007. Allelopathic effect of Calotropis procera leaves extract on seed germination of some plants. Science. 19(1):115-126.

Aristizábal, L. S. R.; Ortíz, A. M. M.; Bedoya, J. G. M. y Jiménez-González, F. J. 2017. Evaluación de la actividad alelopática del extracto en acetato de etilo de Miconia caudata (Bonpl.) dc. Rev. Fac. Cienc. Básic. 13(2):100-104.

Calderon-Fernandez, A. R. 2018. Efecto alelopático de Ruta graveolens, Baccharis alnifolia y Caesalpinia spinosa en la germinación de semillas de Chenopodium album, Amaranthus hybridus, Brassica rapa subsp. campestris y Brassica oleracea var. italica en la región de Arequipa-Perú. Universidad Nacional de San Agustín de Arequipa. Unidad de Posgrado de la Facultad de Ciencias Biológicas. Tesis de Maestría. 79-80 pp.

Carrillo-Martínez, E. J.; Santana-Bejarano, M. B.; Zañudo-Hernández, J. y Hernández-Herrera, R. M. 2018. Imbibición de semillas de frijol mungo (V. radiata) en extractos del alga marina (U. lactuca) y su efecto de la sobre el crecimiento de las plántulas. e-CUCBA. 9(1):35-41.

Celis, Á.; Mendoza, C. F. y Pachón, M. E. 2009. Uso de extractos vegetales en el manejo integrado de plagas, enfermedades y arvenses: revisión. Temas Agrarios. 14(1):5-16.

Dousseau, S.; Alvarenga, A. A. D.; Arantes, L. D. O.; Oliveira, D. M. D. and Nery, F. C. 2008. Germination of Plantago tomentosa Lam. Seeds: influence of the temperature, light and substrate. Ciência e Agrotecnologia. 32(2):438-443.

Figueroa-C, Y. y Galeano, G. 2007. Lista comentada de las plantas vasculares del enclave seco interandino de la tatacoa (Huila, Colombia). Caldasia. 29(2):263-281.

Francisco-Martínez, F. 2018. Conocimiento tradicional, comportamiento productivo y nutritivo de especies leguminosas forrajeras nativas en Tecomatlán, Puebla. Tesis de maestría. 46-51 pp.

Guetat, A.; Abdelwahab, A. T.; Yahia, Y.; Rhimi, W.; Alzahrani, A. K.; Boulila, A.; Cafarchia, C.  y Boussaid, M. 2022. Deverra triradiata Hochst. ex Boiss. from the Northern Region of Saudi Arabia: essential oil profiling, Plant Extracts Biol. Activ. Plants. 11(12):1543.

Hansen, A. M.; Quintanilla, L. G. T.; Pacheco, H. M.; Canela, M. V.; Márquez, L. C. G.; Garcés, R. A. G. y Antonio, A. H. 2013. Atrazina: un herbicida polémico. Rev. Internac. Contamin. Amb. 29(1):65-84.

Hernández, J.; Contreras, Z. E. y Zuluaga, M. S. X. 2008. Intoxicación por paraquat: descripción de un caso clínico. Acta Toxicológica Argentina. 16(1):5-8.

Hernández, Y. y González, M. E. 2010. Efectos de la contaminación microbiana y oxidación fenólica en el establecimiento in vitro de frutales perennes. Cultivos tropicales. 31(4):00-00.

Islam, F.; Wang, J.; Farooq, M. A.; Khan, M. S.; Xu, L.; Zhu, J.; Zhao, M.; Muños, S.; Li, Q. X. and Zhou, W. 2018. Potential impact of the herbicide 2, 4 dichlorophenoxyacetic acid on human and ecosystems. Environ, Inter. 111(1):332-351.

Jácome-Gómez, J. D. y Rojas-Aimacaña, D. A. 2017. Establecimiento del cultivo in vitro de Gaiadendron punctatum (Ruiz y Pav.) G. Don, a partir de yemas y semillas, recolectadas en el cantón mejía. BS tesis. 15-19.

Kakati, B. and Baruah, A. 2013. Allelopathic effect of aqueous extract of some medicinal plants on seed germination and seedling length of mung bean (Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek.). Indian J. Plant Sci. 2(3):8-11

Macías, A. M. 2013. Pequeños agricultores y nueva ruralidad en el occidente de México. Cuadernos de Desarrollo Rural. 10(71):187-207.

Martins-Gomes, C.; Silva, T. L.; Andreani, T. y Silva, A. M. 2022. Exposición a herbicidas a base de glifosato vs glifosato: una revisión sobre su toxicidad. Rev. Xenobióticos. 12(1):21-40.

Mendes, I. D. S. and Rezende, M. O. O. 2014. Assessment of the allelopathic effect of leaf and seed extracts of Canavalia ensiformis as postemergent bioherbicides: a green alternative for sustainable agriculture. J. Environ. Sci. Health, part B. 49(5):374-380.

Muraira, I. G. L.; Cervantes, I.; Ocampo, E.; Díaz, D. y Nava, C. 2016. Agroecología de la maleza en el cultivo de caña en cuatro municipios de Jalisco, México. Ciencia de la maleza. 22-25 pp.

Oliva, C. y Peña, D. 2004. Agricultura orgánica: ¿una alternativa para el desarrollo rural sostenible en la región de coquimbo? Ed. CEDEM. Santiago, Chile. 133 p.

Oliveira, J. S.; Peixoto, C. P.; Poelking, V. G. C. and Almeida, A. T. 2015. Avaliação de extratos das espécies Helianthus annuus, Brachiariabrizanthae Sorghum bicolor com potencial alelopático para uso como herbicida natural. Rev. Brasileira de Plantas Medicinais. 17(3):379-384.

Othman, M. R.; Leong, S. T.; Bakar, B. B.; Awang, K. and Annuar, M. S. M. 2012. Allelopathic potentials of Cuscuta campestris yuncker extracts on germination and growth of radish (Raphanus sativus L.) and lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.). J. Agric. Sci. 4(9):57-63.

Rahman, M. A.; Kheya, S. A.; Hasan, A. K; Anwar, M. P. y Islam, A. K. M. M. 2022. Evaluación del potencial alelopático de extractos de hojas de leguminosas seleccionadas sobre el crecimiento de plántulas de Raphanus sativus. Agricultura Fundamental y Aplicada. 7(3):216-225.

Rojas, M. M. 2018. Consecuencias ambientales y riesgos para la salud causados por el plaguicida paraquat en costa rica. Pensamiento Actual. 18(30):56-66.

Sahu, A. and Devkota, A. 2013. Allelopathic effects of aqueous extract of leaves of Mikania micrantha HBK on seed germination and seedling growht of Oryza sativa L. and Raphanus sativus L. Scientific World. 11(11):91-93.

Swati, V.; Thengane, R. J. and and Ghole, V. S. 2014. Allelopathic effects of Cassia tora and Cassia uniflora on Parthenium hysterophorous L. J. Medicinal Pl. Res. 8(4):194-196.

Uribe-Hernández, R. 2008. Ensayo de Inhibición de la germinación y del alargamiento radicular en semillas de cebolla Allium cepa y soya Glycine max. In: Ramírez, R.; Mendoza, P. y Cantú, A. Libro ensayos toxicológicos para la evaluación de sustancias químicas en agua y suelo. La experiencia en México. México: Secretaría del Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (SEMARNAT). 285-289 pp.